About half of all psychologists did not have openings for new patients in 2024, with capacity issues including longer waitlists and increasingly severe patient symptoms (APA, 2024). That means finding a practice that is accepting new clients is as important as finding the right therapist once you get there. The structure and accessibility of the practice itself can shape your experience from the first call through the end of treatment.
Choosing a practice is not the same as choosing an individual therapist, though the two decisions overlap. The practice determines whether you can get in quickly, whether your insurance is accepted, what specialties are available, and how scheduling works. Those logistics matter as much as clinical fit when you need help now.
What Should You Look for in a Therapy Practice?
Start with availability. Ask if the practice is accepting new clients, what their current wait time is, and when you could expect a first appointment. Some practices have waitlists that stretch weeks or months. Others, particularly smaller or newer practices, can often see new clients within days.
Next, confirm that the practice works with your population. Not every practice serves children, teens, couples, or families. Some focus exclusively on adults. Ask directly whether they treat people in your age group or relationship structure, and whether they have experience with the concern that brought you to therapy.
Then check their areas of clinical expertise. If you are seeking help for anxiety, trauma, OCD, ADHD, or relationship issues, you want a practice where at least one clinician specializes in that area. General therapy can help with many concerns, but specialized training makes a difference for certain conditions.
Finally, clarify the practical details: location (in person or telehealth), hours, fees, insurance, and payment options. These are not secondary considerations. If the logistics do not work for your life, the best therapist in the practice cannot help you.
Why Does Practice Structure Matter?
The difference between a group practice and a solo practitioner is not just about how many therapists work there. It affects accessibility, continuity of care, and what happens if your therapist is unavailable.
Group practices often have shorter wait times because they can distribute new clients across multiple clinicians. A scoping review of healthcare practices found that group practices improved access to care, waiting times, and patient satisfaction, with patients reporting increased access to care and decreased waiting times (Zwiep et al., 2021). When one clinician is at capacity, the practice can match you with another who has openings.
Group practices also offer built in backup. If your therapist is sick, on leave, or unavailable in a crisis, another clinician in the practice can step in. That coverage matters more when you are in acute distress than it does when therapy is stable.
Solo practitioners offer consistency. You work with the same person every session, and there is no handoff or coordination with other providers. Some people prefer that continuity, particularly if they have had negative experiences with fragmented care in the past.
There is no universal better choice. The right structure depends on how quickly you need to start, whether you value the option to switch therapists without leaving the practice, and whether the solo practitioner you are considering has the specific expertise you need.
What Questions Should You Ask Before Your First Appointment?
The American Psychological Association recommends asking about availability, clinical expertise, and practical details before committing to a therapist or practice (APA).
Ask about availability and fit:
- Are you accepting new clients?
- What is your current wait time for a first appointment?
- Do you work with my age group (children, teens, adults, couples, families)?
- How many clinicians are in the practice, and can I be matched with someone based on my needs?
Ask about clinical expertise:
- What areas does the practice specialize in?
- Do you have clinicians with experience treating anxiety, depression, trauma, OCD, ADHD, or whatever brought me here?
- What treatment approaches do you use, and are they evidence based?
Ask about logistics:
- Are sessions in person, by telehealth, or both?
- What hours are available?
- What are your fees?
- Do you accept my insurance, or do you offer a sliding scale?
- What happens if I need to reach someone in a crisis or emergency?
Most practices will answer these questions over the phone or through an online contact form. If a practice will not give you this basic information before you commit to a first session, that tells you something about how they communicate.
How Do You Know If a Practice Specializes in What You Need?
Look at the practice's website and see which services they list as specialties. Most practices name their focus areas clearly: anxiety therapy, trauma therapy, couples counseling, child and adolescent services, or specific modalities like cognitive behavioral therapy or exposure and response prevention.
If the site lists your concern as a specialty and links to a dedicated page about it, that is stronger evidence than a passing mention in a general list. Practices that treat a condition regularly will usually explain their approach to it.
You can also ask directly. When you call or email, say what you are looking for and ask whether they have clinicians with training and experience in that area. A good practice will tell you honestly whether they are a strong match or refer you elsewhere if they are not.
What If the First Practice You Contact Has a Waitlist?
If the practice you want has a long waitlist, ask if they keep a cancellation list. Some practices can fit you in sooner if another client reschedules or drops out.
Ask if they have recommendations for other practices that might have availability. Clinicians often know which of their colleagues are accepting new clients, and a referral from one practice to another can save you time.
Consider whether you are willing to work with any qualified therapist at the practice or whether you need a specific person. If you are open to being matched with whoever has the soonest availability, say so. That flexibility can get you in faster.
If wait times are long across multiple practices, ask whether the practice offers a brief consultation or an initial phone call while you wait. Some practices will do a short assessment to determine urgency and prioritize clients who need immediate care.
Should You Try More Than One Practice Before Deciding?
If you have the option, contacting two or three practices before committing can help you compare availability, cost, and how they respond to your initial questions. You do not need to schedule first appointments at all of them. Just gather information and see which one feels like the best fit based on what you learn.
Some people schedule consultations with more than one practice to get a sense of the culture and communication style. If one practice returns your call within hours and another takes days, or if one answers your questions thoroughly and another gives you minimal information, those differences matter.
Choosing a practice is not like choosing a product where you compare features on a chart. It is more like finding a place where you feel heard and where the logistics actually work for your life. Trust your sense of whether the practice is responsive, transparent, and genuinely interested in helping you get started.
What About Cost and Insurance?
If cost is a concern, ask whether the practice accepts your insurance before you go further. Some practices are in network with many insurers. Others are out of network but can provide a superbill for you to submit for partial reimbursement.
If the practice does not accept insurance, ask about their self pay rates and whether they offer a sliding scale based on income. Many smaller practices will work with you on cost if you ask.
Community mental health centers often charge on a sliding scale and accept Medicaid. University counseling centers sometimes offer low cost therapy provided by graduate students under supervision. Both can be good options if affordability is the main barrier.
Do not avoid reaching out because you assume you cannot afford it. Ask what options are available. The answer might be more flexible than you expect.
When Should You Start Looking?
Start looking before the problem becomes a crisis. Therapy works best when you have enough emotional energy to engage in it, not after you are already overwhelmed.
If your mood, anxiety, relationships, or daily functioning are suffering, or if you have been thinking about therapy for a while, that is reason enough to reach out. Early intervention often prevents symptoms from becoming more entrenched.
The challenge is that when you most need help, the idea of calling multiple practices and waiting for callbacks can feel impossible. If that describes where you are now, ask a friend or family member to help you make the initial calls. Getting past that first step is often the hardest part.
How Do You Decide Between Practices Once You Have Options?
If you have narrowed your search to two or three practices that all seem like reasonable fits, the deciding factors are usually availability, cost, and your gut sense of which one felt most responsive.
The practice that can see you soonest is often the right choice, particularly if you are struggling now. Waiting an extra month for a practice that seems slightly better on paper might not be worth it if another qualified practice can see you this week.
Choosing the right therapist within that practice is the next step, but getting into a practice that is accepting new clients, that treats your concern, and that works with your schedule and budget is the foundation.
What If You Have Already Tried Therapy at Another Practice and It Did Not Work?
If therapy at a different practice did not help, that does not mean therapy will never work for you. It might mean the practice was not the right match, the therapist was not skilled in your specific concern, or you needed a different treatment approach than what they offered.
When you contact a new practice, mention what you tried before and what did not work. That information helps them match you with a clinician who uses a different approach or who has more experience with your particular issue.
Switching practices is not starting over. You bring everything you learned from the first attempt, and a good practice will use that information to tailor the work to what you actually need.
When Should You Reach Out?
If you are in Michigan and looking for a therapy practice that is accepting new clients, Hanna Newton, LMSW, and the team at Advanced Behavioral Health offer evidence based therapy for anxiety, depression, trauma, OCD, ADHD, and relationship concerns by video for children, teens, adults, couples, and families across Michigan. Appointments are often available within the week. Email us at advbehavioralhealth@gmail.com or use the short form at /get-started to start the conversation.
References
American Psychological Association. (2024). Barriers to Care in a Changing Practice Environment: 2024 Practitioner Pulse Survey Full Report. https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/practitioner/2024/practitioner-pulse-2024-full-report.pdf
American Psychological Association. How Do I Find a Good Therapist? https://www.apa.org/ptsd-guideline/patients-and-families/finding-good-therapist
Zwiep, T., Ahn, S., Brehaut, J., Balaa, F., McIsaac, D. I., Rich, S., Wallace, T., & Moloo, H. (2021). Group practice impacts on patients, physicians and healthcare systems: a scoping review. BMJ Open, 11(1), e041579. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7798803/
